Best Choice Roofing: Your Trusted Residential Roofers in New Carlisle, OH
You Chose the Best.
- Building Better Roofs Since 2009
- Long-Lasting Warranties
- Easy Financing Through Goodleap
Protecting Residential Homes in New Carlisle, OH Starts at the Top—With a Roof You Can Rely On
Here in New Carlisle, OH—where small-town charm meets Midwestern grit—your home is more than just a place to sleep. It’s your refuge, your investment, and your foundation. But with Ohio’s ever-changing weather—think freezing winters, humid summers, and the occasional harsh storm—your roof has to be tough enough to handle it all. At Best Choice Roofing, we know exactly what New Carlisle homeowners need: strong, dependable roofing built to last.
Whether your roof is starting to show its age, you’ve spotted storm damage, or you’re just ready for an upgrade, our experienced team is here to walk you through it—every step of the way. We don’t just offer premium roofing solutions; we offer peace of mind. With transparent communication, expert craftsmanship, flexible financing, and some of the best warranties in the business, protecting your home has never been easier (or more stress-free).
Let’s start with a free roof inspection—no pressure, just honest answers.
Residential Roofing Options We Offer in New Carlisle
No two homes—or homeowners—are the same. That’s why our trusted roofing crew is passionate about offering a wide variety of roofing materials and styles to suit your home’s needs, budget, and personal style.
Asphalt Shingle Roofing Solutions in New Carlisle, OH
A favorite among New Carlisle homeowners, asphalt shingles deliver dependable performance and curb appeal without breaking the bank. We install:
Three-Tab Shingles – A budget-friendly classic with clean lines and solid protection.
Architectural Shingles – Add dimension and style with these thicker, more textured shingles.
Premium Shingles – When only the best will do. High-performance, ultra-durable, and stunningly beautiful.
All of our asphalt shingles are designed to resist the elements and hold strong against Ohio’s unpredictable seasons.
Metal Roofing
Looking for something even tougher? Metal roofing is a common option for longevity and energy efficiency. We offer:
Standing Seam Metal Roofing – Sleek and modern, with hidden fasteners for a clean finish.
Corrugated Metal Roofing – Durable, affordable, and full of character with its signature wave-like pattern.
Metal Shingles – Get the traditional look of shingles with the incredible strength and lifespan of metal.
Plus, metal roofs reflect sunlight, keeping your residence much more cool in the summer and helping you save on energy bills.
Why Choose Best Choice Roofing in New Carlisle?
At Best Choice Roofing, we’ve been protecting homes like yours for over 15 years. We combine deep industry experience with a personal, local touch. Our team is here to make the process smooth—from the first inspection to the final nail. And with flexible financing options and industry-leading warranties, we take the stress out of roof replacement.
Call today or book online to schedule your FREE inspection. Let’s make sure your New Carlisle home is covered.
You Chose the Best.
Best Choice Roofing
1839 E Stroop Rd, Kettering
-
Just had Best Choice Roofing do my roof today . TY was a great representative of the company and made sure I was satisfied with everything . The roofers … More were excellent and the clean up was perfect . I made the right choice . -
I am so very happy with my experience with Best Choice Roofing. Sidney was AMAZING. She was kind and caring and put in so much time to ensure State Farm … More took care of us and that was a months long process of her calling, emailing them on my behalf and making special trips out here to take care of what State Farm was requesting. I probably would have given up halfway through the insurance process but Sidney kept pushing through. And in the end it was covered due to hail/wind damage. She made sure we were well taken care of throughout the whole process and she explained everything clearly. The crew was here early and done quickly. The yard was well cleaned up as well. The roof looks great and I am so happy with the whole experience with all of them. Christina was always helpful with my questions when I called the office. Rob was great too when he came to do the walkthrough afterwards. I will absolutely recommend Best Choice and use them for future projects as well.
-
Easy going company to work with. Very knowledgable professional. Shane Hammock was super nice and easy to talk to and never seemed pushy at all. He was … More the biggest reason i chose to hire his company, and I am very satisfied with everything.
-
Worked with my insurance company to replace my roof that was damaged by wind and hail. Sales person, Natalie was great. Kept me informed of the process … More and what was going on. The crew was fast efficient and cleaned up when finished.
-
Had my roof replaced in February during the winter weather and was very pleased with the outcome. The roof looks great and the quality of the work was … More fantastic. About a week after the roof was replaced a manager came to my home to do a quality inspection and answer any questions I had. I was impressed with the whole experience and enjoyed working with Best Choice Roofing.
Service Locations
Weather Damage?
- Leaking Roof
- Missing Shingles
- 10+ Years Old
You Could Be Eligible For A Brand New Roof
Time For A New Roof?
- Old Roof
- Remodeling Your House
- Selling Your Home
You Could Qualify For Low Monthly Payments Through Financing