When it comes to protecting your home, your roof is your first line of defense against Birmingham’s unpredictable weather, from blazing summer heat to sudden thunderstorms. At Best Choice Roofing, we take a lot of pride in helping homeowners throughout Birmingham, AL, keep their roofs strong and stylish. We specialize in top-quality metal roofing and asphalt shingle roofing, offering solutions that look great and last for years.
But before you jump into a new roof project, there’s one big factor to keep in mind if you live in a neighborhood with a homeowners association (HOA): their rules.
HOAs can be fantastic for keeping your community looking beautiful and boosting property values. But they also come with guidelines, and your roof is no exception. So, before you choose shingles or start tearing off old layers, make sure you understand what your HOA allows (and doesn’t allow). Here’s why it matters and the top considerations to keep in mind.
Why You Should Care About HOA Roof Rules
In Birmingham, many neighborhoods have HOAs designed to maintain a cohesive, polished look throughout the community. These associations often have strict guidelines about exterior home improvements, including your roof’s color, material, and style.
Not listening to these rules can result in fines, legal headaches, and, in some cases, being forced to redo your roof, an expensive and stressful situation no one wants!
Luckily, at Best Choice Roofing, we’ve worked with countless homeowners in HOA communities and can help you navigate these requirements with ease. Here are the top roof considerations to think about if you have an HOA in Birmingham.
1. Approved Roofing Materials
Your HOA may have a specific list of approved roofing materials. Some communities might allow traditional asphalt shingles but forbid metal roofing due to aesthetic uniformity. In other words, metal roofing could be encouraged because of its durability and modern look.
Birmingham homeowners often choose asphalt shingles because they’re cost-effective, versatile, and come in a huge variety of colors and styles. But if you’re dreaming of a sleek standing seam metal roof, check that your HOA is on board before making any decisions.
At Best Choice Roofing, we offer both asphalt and metal options and can help you find the perfect fit that meets your HOA’s guidelines while still protecting your home from Alabama’s ever-changing weather.

2. Roof Color Restrictions
HOAs often maintain strict color palettes to keep a consistent look throughout the neighborhood. While you might love the idea of a bold, dark roof to make your home stand out, your HOA may require earth tones or certain neutral shades.
Before you pick a color sample, ask your HOA for a list of approved colors. Our team can help you choose a hue that not only enhances your curb appeal but also keeps you in compliance (and out of trouble with the HOA board!).
3. Roof Pitch and Style
Some HOAs even dictate the style and pitch (slope) of your roof. They may prefer gable roofs over flat ones or require a certain pitch to match the architectural vibe of the neighborhood.
If your HOA has these restrictions, it’s crucial to confirm them before making any design changes. Choosing the wrong roof shape can lead to a forced redo, which means wasted time and money.
When you work with Best Choice Roofing, we’ll help you navigate these design details and ensure your new roof complements your home — and satisfies your HOA’s standards.
4. Approval Process and Timeline
Replacing or installing a new roof in an HOA neighborhood isn’t as simple as calling your favorite roofing company (although we wish it were!). In most cases, you’ll need to submit an application to your HOA’s architectural review committee.
This application usually includes detailed plans, materials, color samples, and sometimes even contractor information. The approval process can take a few weeks, so it’s best to start early.
At Best Choice Roofing, we can provide the necessary documentation and support to make your approval process smooth and stress-free. We’ll help you prepare everything your HOA needs, so you can focus on looking forward to your beautiful new roof rather than stressing about paperwork.
Let Best Choice Roofing Take the Stress Out of Roofing
Your roof should be a source of pride, not a source of HOA drama. Whether you’re dreaming of a brand-new metal roof or classic asphalt shingles, Best Choice Roofing has your back in Birmingham, AL. Our reliable roofing team knows the ins and outs of HOA guidelines in Birmingham and can help you select the perfect roofing solution that meets all requirements and looks stunning.
Ready to upgrade your roof and keep your HOA happy? Contact Best Choice Roofing today for a free inspection and consultation. We’ll guide you through every step, from selecting the right materials to handling HOA approvals, so you can sit back and enjoy the view from under your beautiful new roof!