Best Choice Roofing: Your Trusted Residential Roofers in Upper Arlington, OH
You Chose the Best.
- Building Better Roofs Since 2009
- Long-Lasting Warranties
- Easy Financing Through Goodleap
Protecting Upper Arlington Homes Starts at the Top — With Best Choice Roofing
In Upper Arlington, OH, where tree-lined streets, historic charm, and modern luxury coexist, your home isn’t just a place to live; it’s a reflection of everything you’ve built. And when it comes to protecting that investment, a dependable, high-quality roof is essential. That’s where Best Choice Roofing comes in.
We know Upper Arlington homeowners face a unique mix of seasonal challenges, from icy winter winds sweeping off the Scioto River to heavy summer downpours that test even the toughest rooftops. Our team specializes in roofing systems built to take on Ohio’s unpredictable weather while complementing the elegant aesthetics this community is known for.
From the red-brick Colonials near Lane Avenue to modern builds tucked into quiet cul-de-sacs, we offer personalized roofing solutions that match your home’s architecture, value, and your family’s peace of mind. Whether it’s a repair, replacement, or fresh installation, we make the process seamless, with expert craftsmanship, clear communication, and long-lasting warranties to back it all up.
Schedule your free roof inspection today in Upper Arlington, OH, and experience the Best Choice Roofing difference!
Roofing Options for Upper Arlington Homes
We offer a full selection of roofing systems, hand-picked for durability, style, and performance in the local climate. Whether you’re upgrading a traditional look or modernizing your home’s curb appeal, we’ve got you covered.
Asphalt Shingle Roofing
Still, the most popular option for good reason, asphalt shingles are cost-effective, reliable, and come in a wide range of styles. We offer:
Three-Tab Shingles: Classic and clean-cut, ideal for homeowners looking for reliable performance on a budget.
Architectural Shingles: Dimensional shingles that offer added visual appeal and a longer lifespan.
Premium Shingles: High-end aesthetics and maximum durability for luxury homes.
Impact-Resistant Shingles: Engineered to handle Ohio’s hailstorms and flying debris, ideal for storm-prone seasons.
Metal Roofing
Want something built for longevity? Thanks to its energy efficiency and sleek design, metal roofing has become a top choice for discerning homeowners in Upper Arlington.
Standing Seam Metal Roofs: Modern, weather-tight, and built to last 40+ years.
Corrugated Metal: Tough and distinctive, with a classic profile that adds character.
Exposed Fastener Panels: Cost-effective and efficient for quicker installs.
Metal Shingles: The perfect blend of form and function, combining the look of traditional shingles with the strength of metal.
Why Homeowners in Upper Arlington Choose Best Choice Roofing
We don’t just install roofs, we deliver peace of mind. Our licensed, experienced team takes pride in every job, offering local knowledge, fast response times, and personalized recommendations to suit your home and budget. Whether you’re in need of a full replacement after a storm or you’re just curious about your roof’s condition, we’re here to help, with no pressure and a whole lot of integrity.
Ready to get started? Book your free inspection with Best Choice Roofing in Upper Arlington, OH, and protect your home the right way.
You Chose the Best.
Best Choice Roofing
3148 Broadway #305, Grove City
-
Best Choice Roofing is absolutely amazing! From start to finish, the entire process was smooth, professional, and stress-free. Natalie, the general manager, … More went above and beyond to make sure everything was handled perfectly, she truly cares about her customers and takes pride in her work. Tammy was so friendly and organized; she kept me updated every step of the way and made communication effortless.The crew did a fantastic job on my roof—fast, efficient, and with great attention to detail. They left everything spotless afterward, too. It’s clear that this company values quality and customer satisfaction. I highly recommend Best Choice Roofing to anyone looking for reliable service and a team that genuinely stands behind their work! -
I never leave reviews but my experience was so great that I had to shout them out. Natalie was so pleasant and answered all of my questions with enthusiasm … More and accuracy. Josh and Tammy went out of their way to help and get me what I needed. This was my first time getting a roof installation, and I will definitely be reffering this company to friends and family. Best Choice Roofing really was the best choice!!! thank you :)))
-
Jackson Thomas was great he give Great price and follow thought with game plan.Office did great job get sch call me let they would be here.crew was great … More take off old roof and found some bad plywood replace it.Found 1 plywood that hole burn in it look like fire work land on it set side so i could see it.Did great job clean up.person in charge here 2 time check on crew and here on when they compete job long JACKSON THOMAS HERE On complete job for walk round inspection make sure that I that happen with work.Best thing said about JACKSON THOMAS THAT go great detail about they going start to finish on job.I talk 3 time job was done and he want to make sure i like work done. IF up I would give everyone raise BEST CHOICE ROOFING AND if every need new roof 1 Call and only call will be BEST CHOICE ROOFING.THANK FOR GREAT JOB. THANK TO JACKSON THOMAS
-
7-15-2025*Updated review* I am updating my previous review of Best Choice Roofing. First my apologies to Rudy Moreno. I wrote the previous review due … More to other experiences with companies and a fear of trusting door-to-door representatives. Initially I tried to send PDF documents to Rudy’s phone that, for whatever reason, didn’t go through via my phone or email. I got upset and thought the worse. In my frustration I didn’t think to try to call him. However Rudy and his co-worker showed up the next day as he promised. He returned the following day, on a Saturday no less, to help me with my insurance company and to get the ball rolling. Two of other companies dropped the ball with no communication. Whatever happens and I am hoping for the best, I am giving 5 stars because he proved me wrong. There are people who do care and will try their best to help.—————————————————————————7-11-2025Someone by the name of Rudy Moreno (which was NOT his name) was canvassing in my area yesterday and came to my home. I discussed the situation with my home and he stated he would work with me. I told him immediately please don't BS me as I had already been through this and prefer someone be truthful. He supposedly wrote down his number and email to send him information I received from my insurance company for him to "take a look to see what he could do". Of course when I sent the email it came back saying the email address does not exist and neither does the telephone number. He also made an appointment for today to come back to discuss options and said he would also clean the gutter at the front of my home at no charge. It had started to rain while he was at my home and he saw water was draining through my awning and not through the down spout. When he said he would clean my gutter, I knew immediately he was lying. I may be a senior but I am not stupid. Even if there was something this company could help me with I wouldn't trust them. I don't want a response so don’t bother contacting me.. I just want others to know this company is not reputable. If someone they sent to canvas my neighborhood couldn't be truthful why would I trust them if contracted to do work? I have a limited income and don't need the nonsense. My roof will be repaired eventually but definitely not by this company. They are a member of the BBB, so check the BBB reviews too, so buyer beware.
-
Just had my roof installed today. The Rep who helped me get everything set up was in and out all day to help with any issues. Zach did a wonderful job … More of making sure everything was handled with care. The installers were fast and efficient, done in an day. Would recommend to anyone who needs a roof.
Service Locations
Weather Damage?
- Leaking Roof
- Missing Shingles
- 10+ Years Old
You Could Be Eligible For A Brand New Roof
Time For A New Roof?
- Old Roof
- Remodeling Your House
- Selling Your Home
You Could Qualify For Low Monthly Payments Through Financing